Revista de Gestão Costeira Integrada
Volume 15, Número 2, Junho 2015, Páginas 167-178

DOI: 10.5894/rgci572
* Submission: 23 DEC 2014; Peer review: 8 FEB 2015; Revised: 18 FEB 2015; Accepted: 23 FEB 2015; Available on-line: 25 FEB 2015

Supporting Information (410KB, PDF)

Situação ecológica, socioeconómica e de governança após a implementação do primeiro plano de ordenamento no Parque Marinho Professor Luiz Saldanha (Arrábida, Portugal):
II – percepções de utentes *  

Yorgos Stratoudakis^{@, a}; Flávio Fernández^a; Miguel Henriques^b;
João Martins^b, Rogélia Martins^a

---

@ - Corresponding author, to whom correspondence should be addressed. e-mail: <[email protected]>
a - IPMA, Instituto Português do Mar e da Atmosfera IP, Avenida de Brasília s/n; 1449-006; Lisboa, Portugal.
b - ICNF, Instituto da Conservação da Natureza e das Florestas IP, Parque Natural de Arrábida, Praça da República; 2900-587; Setúbal, Portugal.     

---

RESUMO
O Parque Marinho Professor Luiz Saldanha (PMLS) foi criado em 1998 e está regulado por um plano de ordenamento desde 2005. Este estudo apresenta os resultados de um inquérito que recolheu percepções de utentes do PMLS sobre a situação ecológica, socioeconómica e de governança 4-7 anos após a implementação faseada das regras nesta área marinha protegida (AMP). As 37 perguntas sobre o sistema social-ecológico e algumas perguntas auxiliares foram respondidas por 64 utentes do PMLS divididos em seis categorias alvo: pescadores profissionais a operar fora do PMLS, pescadores lúdicos, mergulhadores, investigadores, elementos da administração e outra. Diferente estratégia de amostragem foi seguida para cada categoria de utentes, em função do conhecimento prévio de indivíduos com elevado nível de familiaridade com os assuntos do inquérito. Foram respondidas 1694 das 2368 perguntas colocadas (71.5% de resposta, com ausência de resposta na grande maioria dos casos por desconhecimento). As respostas agregadas foram utilizadas para formar indicadores de tendência para assuntos relevantes para qualquer AMP e comparadas estatisticamente com uma distribuição de respostas teórica normal, centrada na percepção de ausência de mudança. Foi também considerado o efeito da opinião pessoal do inquirido sobre o PMLS, avaliando a existência de diferenças significativas na distribuição das respostas de “optimistas” (inquiridos cuja aceitação do PMLS melhorou nos últimos anos) versus restantes. No geral, das respostas dos utentes sobressai uma visão positiva para a evolução do PMLS e da sua interacção com a pesca até 2012, com a excepção de alguns aspectos socioeconómicos importantes ligados à pesca. Existe também alguma variabilidade de perspectivas entre categorias (nomeadamente para assuntos ecológicos) e foram detectados seis casos de diferenças significativas na distribuição de respostas entre “optimistas” e restantes. Comparando estes resultados com os resultados do inquérito para os pescadores do PMLS (Stratoudakis et al., 2015), denota-se a prevalência de uma divergência de percepções nos assuntos ecológicos (com os pescadores a não detectar melhorias) e de uma convergência nos assuntos socioeconómicos e de governança. O objectivo conjunto destes trabalhos é apoiar a avaliação da eficácia de gestão no processo de revisão do plano de ordenamento do PMLS e a iniciação de um plano de monitorização longitudinal focado em metodologias participativas.

Palavras-chave: AMP, Sistema Social-Ecológico, Monitorização Participativa, Questionário, Avaliação de Eficácia de Gestão.

Ecological, socioeconomic and governance conditions after the implementation of the first spatial plan in the Prof. Luiz Saldanha Marine Park (Arrábida, Portugal): II – user perceptions

ABSTRACT
The Prof. Luiz Saldanha Marine Park (PMLS – Arrábida, Portugal) was created in 1998 and has been managed according to a spatial plan since 2005. This study presents the results from an inquiry on the perceptions of PMLS users in relation to the ecological, socioeconomic and governance situation in the Park 4-7 years after the phased implementation of spatial rules in this Marine Protected Area (MPA). The 37 questions on the social-ecological system and some auxiliary questions were answered by 64 PMLS users from six categories: fishers operating outside the MPA, recreational fishers, divers, researchers, public administration and others. A distinct sampling strategy was followed for each user category depending on the level of previous knowledge of people with high level of familiarity with the questionnaire issues (close to a census on researchers and public administration members with specific activity in PMLS; snowball sampling for professional and recreational fishers; and provision of contacts of experienced divers from the Portuguese Centre of Sub-aquatic Activities). Respondents were asked to indicate their perception of improvement (moderate or large), stability or deterioration (moderate or large) on an ordinal scale of possible responses (5 levels Likert-type scale) for each of the issues at question. In total, 1694 replies were obtained to the 2368 questions placed (response rate of 71.5%, with the great majority of non-response being due to lack of knowledge). Aggregated replies were used to construct trend indicators on issues relevant for any MPA and were compared statistically with a series of samples from a theoretical distribution of replies centered in the lack of change (standardized normal distribution, truncated at 2 standard deviations). The effect of respondent opinion on the PMLS was tested by comparing the distribution of replies between “optimists” (people whose opinion of the PMLS improved in the last 4-5 years) and others. Overall, user replies indicate a positive view on the evolution of the PMLS and its interaction with small scale fisheries until 2012, with 2.04 replies of perceived improvement for every reply of perceived deterioration. This ratio was substantially lower for socioeconomic issues, where a perceived significant improvement in PMLS knowledge and its dissemination were counterbalanced by a perceived deterioration in the ability of excluded fishers to maintain a living related to fishing and the attraction of fishing as employment for youth. This contrast is also detected when comparing the distribution of replies to 5 socioeconomic and governance questions identically phrased with respect to fishers and other users: on two issues (earnings and management solutions) the same group of respondents considered that the evolution in the last 4-5 years was significantly better for other users than for fishers (although no significant difference was found in the evolution of group conflicts with the MPA managing authority). Variation in replies was detected among user categories (mainly in ecological issues), while significant differences between the replies of “optimists” and others were only found in 6 questions (PMLS acceptance by fishers, other users and local community; attraction of fishing as employment for youth; coverage by brown macroalgae and sightings of seabirds and marine mammals). Comparing these results with those of the inquiry to PMLS fishers (Stratoudakis et al., 2015) there is a prevalence of a divergence in perceptions for ecological issues (with PMLS fishers not detecting the improvements perceived by other users) and a convergence in socioeconomic and governance issues (both those indicating improvement and those indicating deterioration). The joint objective of these two studies is to inform the management effectiveness evaluation that is included in the process of revision of the spatial plan for the PMLS and to set the basis for a longitudinal monitoring plan focusing on participatory methods.   

Keywords: MPA, Social-Ecological System, Participatory Monitoring, Questionnaire, Management Effectiveness Evaluation. 

 

Batista, M.I.; Baeta, F.; Costa, M.J.; Cabral, H.N. (2011) - MPA as
management tools for small-scale fisheries: the case-study of
Arrábida Marine Protected Area (Portugal). Ocean and Coastal
Management, 54(2):137-147. DOI: 10.1016/j.ocecoaman.2010.10.032

Cabral, H.N.; Batista M.; Baeta, F.; Alves, A.; Costa, M.J. (2008) -
Avaliação do impacto das condicionantes na Área Marinha do Parque Natural de Arrábida à actividade da pesca comercial e lúdica, a náutica de recreio e ao mergulho. Relatório Final. Instituto de Oceanografia, FCUL, Lisboa. 242 pp + anexos. Não publicado.

Carneiro, G. (2011) – The Luiz Saldanha Marine Park: an overview of conflicting perceptions. Conservation and Society, 9(4): 325-333.
DOI: 10.4103/0972-4923.92149

Cunha, A.H., Erzini, K., Serrão, E.A., Gonçalves, E., Borges, R., Henriques, M., Henriques, V., Guerra, M., Duarte, C., Marbá, N., Fonseca, M. (2014) – Biomares, a LIFE Project to restore and manage the biodiversity of Prof. Luiz Saldanha Marine Park. Journal of Coastal Conservation. 18(6):643-655. DOI: 10.1007/s11852-014-0336-x

Davis, A.; Wagner, J.R. (2003) – Who knows? On the importance of
identifying “experts” when researching local ecological knowledge.
Human Ecology, 31(3):463-489. Article Stable URL:
http://www.jstor.org/stable/4603485

Davis, A.; Hanson, J.M.; Watts, H.; MacPherson H. (2004) – Local
ecological knowledge and marine fisheries research: the case of white hake (Urophycis tenuis) predation on juvenile American lobster (Homarus americanus). Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 61(7):1191-1201. DOI: 10.1139/F04-070

Henriques, M.; Gonçalves, E.J.; Almada, V.C. (2007) - Rapid shifts
in a marine fish assemblage follow fluctuations in winter sea
conditions. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 340:259-270.

Henriques, S.; Pais, M.P.; Costa, M.J.; Cabral, H.N. (2013) – Seasonal
variability of rocky fish assemblages: detecting functional and structural changes due to fishing effort. Journal of Sea Research, 79:50-59.
DOI: 10.1016/j.seares.2013.02.004

Henriques, V.; Guerra, M.T.; Mendes, B.; Gaudêncio, M.J., Fonseca, P. (in press) – Benthic habitat mapping in a Portuguese marine protected area using EUNIS: an integrated approach. Journal of Sea Research.
DOI: 10.1016/j.seares.2014.10.007

Horta e Costa, B.; Gonçalves, E. (2013) – First occurrence of the
Monrovia doctorfish Acanthurus monroviae (Perciformes: Acanthuriade) in European Atlantic waters. Marine Biodiversity Records, 6:e20.
DOI: 10.1017/S1755267213000055

Horta e Costa, B.; Erzini, K.; Caselle, J.E.; Folhas, H.; Gonçalves, E. (2013) - “Reserve effect” within a temperate marine protected area in the North-eastern Atlantic (Arrábida Marine Park, Portugal). Marine Ecology Progress Series, 481:11-24. DOI: 10.3354/meps10204

Leleu, K., Alban, F., Pelletier, D., Charbonnel, E., Letourneur, Y.,
Boudouresque, C.F. (2012) – Fishers´ perceptions as indicators of the performance of Marine protected Areas (MPAs). Marine Policy 36(2):414-422. DOI: 10.1016/j.marpol.2011.06.002

Norman, G. (2010) – Likert scales, levels of measurement and the
“laws” of statistics. Advances in Health Science Education,
15(5):625-632. DOI: 10.1007/s10459-010-9222-y

Pajaro, M.G.; Mulrennan, M.E.; Alder, J.; Vincent, A.C.J. (2010) -
Developing MPA effectiveness indicators: comparison within and across stakeholder groups and communities. Coastal Management 38:122-143. DOI: 10.1080/08920751003633094

Pomeroy, R.S.; Parks, J.; Watson, L. (2004) - How is your MPA doing? A guidebook of natural and social indicators for evaluating marine protected areas and management effectiveness. IUCN, Gland, Switzerland and Cambridge, UK. Xvi + 216 pp. ISBN: 2-8317-0735-8; 978-2-8317-0735-8. Available online at https://portals.iucn.org/library/
node/8417

R Core Team (2014) - R: A language and environment for statistical
computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria. Available online at http://www.R-project.org/

Stratoudakis, Y.; Fernándes, F.; Henriques, M.; Martins, J.; Martins
R. (2015) – Situação ecológica, socioeconómica e de
governança após a implementação do primeiro plano de ordenamento
no Parque Marinho professor Luiz Saldanha (Arrábida,
Portugal): I – informações e opiniões de pescadores. Journal of
Integrated Coastal Zone Management, XX

Tversky, A.; Kahneman, D. (1974) – Judgment under uncertainty:
heuristics and biases. Science, 185(4157):1124-1131.
DOI: 10.1126/science.185.4157.1124

Yasué, M.; Kaufman, L.; Vincent, A.C.J. (2010) – Assessing ecological
changes in and around marine reserves using community perceptions and biological surveys. Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems, 20(4):407-418. DOI: 10.1002/aqc.1090

Vasconcelos, L.; Caser, U.; Pereira, M.J.R.; Gonçalves, G.; Sá, R. (2012) - MARGOV – Building social sustainability. Journal of Coastal Conservation, 16(4):523-530. DOI: 10.1007/s11852-012-0189-0

 

em construção